Best Sump Pump Reviews 2017 – 2018

A sump pump is usually available for sale at waterproofing contractors, plumbing wholesalers, or DIY retailers. It can be as expensive as $500 or as affordable as $60 depending on the make, model, and grade of the sub pump in question. It all depends on the features and quality of the pump in question that you wish to purchase.

You also have to decide whether you should get a pedestal or submersible sump pump. While the pedestal one is more visible, the submersible variety is more out of earshot and out of sight, so it’s thusly out of your mind and hair (which many homeowners prefer). This is particularly beneficial if your primary living area or shelter is the basement. You don’t want some noisy pump ruining your sleep or your enjoyment in your den of sorts. The sump pump uses ¼ HP to 1 HP of power to remove water from the sump and discharge it away from the foundation of your home.

With that said, if you go the pedestal pump route, you’ll get something that’s easier to repair and much more affordable. On the other hand, a submersible pump is also in many ways safer around children if your house is already home to bundles of joy. It’s out of their reach, they won’t sabotage the machine by their horseplay, and in turn, they won’t get hurt by the machine in question either.

A sub sump pump is capable of sitting in water a good deal of the time, so they last from half a decade to a decade and a half. As for pedestals, they could last from 25 to 30 years exactly because they’re not sitting on water, which can be corrosive. The submersible is more frequently used by default since it’s sitting in the water itself. Expect most makers to offer you limited one-year warranties for their offerings.

PictureModelEditor RatingsOur Review
Superior Pump 91250 (BEST SELLER) (4.5 / 5)
1577+ Reviews
Our Review
WAYNE WAPC250 Cover Pump (4.3 / 5)
563+ Reviews
Our Review
Wayne PC2 Portable Transfer Water Pump (4.3 / 5)
405+ Reviews
Our Review
Liberty Pumps 257 Submersible Sump (4.7 / 5)
217+ Reviews
Our Review
Zoeller 98-0001 Submersible Sump (4.5 / 5)
245+ Reviews
Our Review
Zoeller M53 Submersible Sump Pump (4.6 / 5)
387+ Reviews
Our Review

Best Sump Pump Reviews

Superior Pump 91250 ¼ HP Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump

This is a sump pump best seller indeed as far as is concerned. The Superior Pump 91250 Utility Pump epitomizes everything that makes a sump pump work (thusly answering “how does a sump pump work?”).

It’s not only backed by a one-year limited warranty (which is par for the course with all sump pumps), but it’s also designed for consistent, reliable domestic use (or as the Superior Pump brand would claim). Its specs include ¼ HP of pure engine strength, over 1,800 gallons per hour of flow rate, over 1,200 GPH at ten feet of discharge lift, and a bottom suction design that allows it to filter debris and remove water down to ⅛ of an inch in surface terms.

But wait, there’s more! The Superior Pump 91250 also passes solids of ⅛ of an inch as well. It’s a submersible type of pump that was able to tickle the fancy of quite a lot of consumers out there thanks to how long-lasting and durable it is with its double-sealed thermoplastic construction. It also comes with a 10-foot cord, a large 1¼-inch discharge with ¾-inch garden hose adapter, and consistent operation that can handle even the rainiest of days or the most flooded of basements full of groundwater.

It’s so powerful it can drain standing water from not only basements but also fountains and swimming pools, thus you don’t only rely on drainage systems to get rid of unwanted water post haste. Most importantly, the Superior Pump 91250 was developed for the homeowner in mind. You don’t need to be a rocket scientist to operate this pump. See our detailed review of the Superior Pump 91250 here.

WAYNE WAPC250 Water Removal Pool Cover Pump

WAYNE WAPC250 1/4 HP Automatic ON/OFF Water Removal Pool Cover Pump

The Wayne or WAYNE WAPC250 Pump has a  lot to offer in terms of quality sump pump action, starting with its iSwitch Technology that has an auto freeze protection that prevents pump damage. The same cutting-edge tech serves as an automatic switch that turns the pump on and off as needed without any human presence.

All it needs is to sense the presence of water and it will pump the water away. This is important because it can be a huge waste of electricity to have to manually turn on the pump, only for you to forget to switch it back off. It also serves as a great safety measure of sorts. Meanwhile, the Wayne WAPC250 is also energy efficient in its own right because it’s an oil-free pump with a high flow rate.

What’s more, the pump is pretty much a plug-it-and-leave sort of device kind of like your refrigerator that automatically shuts off when enough coldness has been achieved or your humidifier that switches off when the room is plenty humid already. It’s a smart kind of pump that you’ve been looking for.

If you wish for worry-free water removal, then this is the pump that you should definitely acquire. You will use this unit 100% of the time because it’s a long-lasting kind of anti-corrosive pump with a strainer base that filters debris and will assuredly keep working even in the dankest and wettest of conditions.

It’s able to minimize clogging and its base is also well-balanced enough to keep the unit from tipping over. What more can you ask for from the WAYNE WAPC250 Pool Cover Pump? It has everything you’re looking for in an affordable sump pump and more. Read our detailed review of the WAYNE WAPC250 here.

Wayne PC2 Portable Transfer Water Pump Bronze

As for the WAYNE Portable Transfer Water Pump Bronze, it’s a heavy-duty kind of sump pump with housing that’s bronze-plated to ensure durability. If the all-bronze Statue of Liberty was able to last the salty sea that surrounded it for hundreds of years with discoloration as its main issue, then you can certainly get long-lasting operation on the bronze-plated PC2 115-Volt 340 GPH Portable Transfer Water Pump. Aside from being built like a tank, the Wayne PC2 is also quite portable for something so reinforced, thus allowing you loads of utility and household applications.

What that means is that you can move it all around the house to get rid of any flooding or stagnant water in your home, from a clogged drain to gutters that need to have their muck cleaned out ASAP. A standard garden hose can also be used on its discharge since it’s threaded to accept any hose unto it universally.

What’s more, the WAYNE PC2 Portable Transfer Water Pump is also capable of pumping up to 340 gallons of water per hour (or 5.7 gallons per minute). The obvious downside to a portable water pump is less capacity for water pumping compared to the bigger, industrial-level pumps on this list. However, its flexibility and zero-feet discharge head of 300 GPH at 10 feet cannot be denied. It’s still a must-have pump that can remove water down to ⅛ inch of the surface. Read our detailed review of the Wayne PC2 here.

Liberty Pumps Automatic Submersible Sump

In regards to the Liberty Pumps Automatic Submersible Sump with VMF Switch, you won’t go wrong in picking this pump. After all, it’s capable of pumping 50 gallons per minute. Not as much as the Zoeller model, but it outdoes the best-seller Superior Pump model since that one has a 30 gallon per minute or 1,800 gallon per hour rate. Clearly, the Liberty Pumps 257 is the one with the better pumping rate.

Meanwhile, its maximum discharge head is at 21 feet, which is only 2 feet under the discharge head of the Zoeller 98-001 M98 Flow-Mate. It can also get rid of solids that are about ½ inch in size thanks to its efficient motor design that mitigates excessive electrical usage by up to 40%.

The Liberty Pumps 257 isn’t only a decent sump pump; it can also double as an effluent pump plus it has over 257 features according to its advertising. One of its key features, the VMF switch, is magnetically operated so that it can be used on smaller pits down to a 10-inch diameter. This unit even has a longer warranty than usual, for about three years.

This faith in their product serves as your guarantee that even with heavy usage, the sump pump will continue to operate for at least three years or your money back (or a new unit is delivered to you) depending on the stipulations of the contract. See our detailed review of the Liberty Pumps 257 here.

Zoeller 98-0001 Submersible Sump/Effluent Pump

As for the Zoeller 98-0001 Submersible Sump, you can tell by its page name that it’s quite the “beauty” and the “beast” in terms of features and functions. Don’t worry about the sump pump installation cost either, since this model is quite easy to install on your own or cheaply enough with the help of a pro.

The Zoeller 98-0001 comes complete with the ability to pass ½-inch spherical solids with the liquids it pumps out of your basement or pool by default. It’s also on-point at 9½ inches and off-point 3 inches. Thanks to its ability to pump 72 gallons every minute with a five-foot head, you’ll deal with any flooding or standing water issue in minutes.

Zoeller 98-0001 is also a must-have sump pump because of its cast-iron motor and pump housing that ensures it will last you for quite a long time. Everything about this piece of equipment is cast iron. It has a cast iron base, cast iron switch case, and so forth. The iron is Class 25-20, which means it is high-grade iron that can deal with the corrosive powers of regular groundwater-pumping usage.

It also includes a 15-foot, 3-wire neoprene cord and a shut-off head that’s 23 feet. The Zoeller 98-0001 also sports a precision-engineered and heavy-duty plastic vortex impeller that helps in its smooth operation every time. There’s also the fact that the Flow-Mate has an epoxy finish that’s corrosion-resistant and powder-coated. Every last spec needed to make it last against regular use has been included in this unit. Read our detailed review of the Zoeller 98-0001 here.

Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump

As for this second Zoeller entry on this list, it also has a lot to offer. To wit, the Zoeller M53 has a ⅓ HP motor, a 1½-inch NPT discharge and passes for ½-inch solids that are spherical (which means anything larger than ½ of an inch will be filtered out to prevent clogging), a vortex impeller design that assures now clogging will assure on top of its top-notch filtration system, a switch case that’s made out of durable cast iron, and a pump housing and motor that’s also made of the same anti-corrosion material.

It also automatically switches on and off, but this time it makes use of float technology. To wit, its switch is float-activated so that when the water in your basement or pool reaches a certain height thanks to rainwater and groundwater, it will automatically turn itself on.

It then pumps the water away until the floater goes back down to solid ground. It only requires, at most, periodic service. As long as it’s well-maintained and you don’t do anything abusive to it during operation, you can rest assure that the Zoeller M53 will last you a long, long time. This is a bombproof product in every step of the way.

If the switch gets broken, you can easily replace it with the help of a screwdriver. It can probably last three to six years depending on the conditions of your area. If there’s heavy rain there as though you’re in the Amazon jungle, then perhaps three years is what you should expect. If the floods are intermittent in your neck of the woods, then you can expect the switch to last about six years. Read our detailed review of the Zoeller M53 here.

Sump Pump Buying Guide

Sump Pump Basics

A sump pump consists of the following parts. A discharge hose or pipe, a primary sump pump, a sump basin, a groundwater collection system, a check valve, and a backup sump pump. The discharge pipe or hose is a pipe or an open valve that carries the water to be discharged away from your house and its foundations.

As for the primary sump pump, it’s powered by a ¼ HP to 1 HP motor. Whether you avail of a flotec sump pump or some other brand, submersible or pedestal, you need to keep in mind the following. Meanwhile, the sump basin is the container that collects that liquid that’s supposed to be removed from your home. In turn, this water is collected by the groundwater collection system that routes the excessive groundwater right into the basis in an efficient, draining manner. As for the check valve, it keeps backflow from the discharge outlet from happening.

In other words, it keeps water pumped out of the basis from flowing back into the place from where it came from when you turn off your sump pump. It’s a one-way discharge street thanks to the check valve. Finally, the backup sump pump system is an optional part of the setup that can provide added protection in the event of a power failure. It can also serve as a substitute pump during primary pump failures.

As many sump pump reviews would take note, the materials used to make up the pump can affect the price of the sump pump. You should search for housings and parts that are made of alloy, non-corrosive, such as cast-iron with epoxy coating, stainless steel, or cast bronze material. Avoid using sheet metal. Plastics related to polypropylene are utilized in pumps of all grades. You should pay attention to the length of the power cord, which comes in 5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 feet variations in terms of lengths.

Switches and Other Considerations

There are several types of switches on sump pumps, and they include mercury, diaphragm, and float switches. It doesn’t matter what your choice in switches, but make sure as much as possible you get the automatic type. The problem with manual control pumps is that they might malfunction at the worst possible time. One wrong move or one forgetful afternoon, and you might end up forgetting to turn it on the next time your basement gets flooded with water.

The best sump pumps are those that automatically switch on even if you forget to switch it on, saving you the hassle of remembering to switch them on or off every time. The automatic switch can serve as a pump safeguard of sorts as well, in that it protects it from running dry for too long. It automatically switches the pump on and off as needed without your supervision, which has enormous implications.

Remember, the strength of the unit is related to its price. The best switches from the best pumps are those that are corrosion-free and have the right capacity. When selecting your pump, its capacity should coincide with the bigness of your basement and the amount of water that needs to be pumped out. Capacity is measured by gallons per hour or gallons per minute. That’s what you should watch out for when reading battery backup sump pump reviews as well.

You should also know the height of the water that has to be vertically lifted in order to be removed (in other words, you should know the head pressure). The head pressure rating should be enough to lift water high enough to get it out of your crawlspace or basement. Pick the pumps that are engineered to lift at least 10 feet. The packaging should indicate both the head limitations and flow rates.


As mentioned earlier, a sump pump unit’s strength is related to how much it is. With that said, you should maximize your investment by making sure that everything is on the up and up when it comes to the capabilities of every pump mentioned above. Thankfully, the selection was made to ensure optimum cost-efficiency.

So what is the best sump pump? The right question to ask is what the best pump is for you, actually. As much as possible, don’t buy anything cheap because they’re the weakest. If you haven’t enough money to buy a pump, save for one. In this case, being a cheapskate isn’t the best option. You have to consider this as one of your major home investments, like buying a refrigerator or a car. You can get a sump pump that’s ½ or ⅙ HP. It can even be powerful enough to have a 1 HP motor.

In order to remove groundwater from your home and prevent basement damage, you need to buy and install the right sump pump. If you live in a city or area where there’s loads of heavy rain and there’s a tendency for flooding, then you should have a sump pump. Ditto if you live in regions where it’s below sea level and groundwater is an everyday reality. It’s your best bet and protection against accumulated groundwater and moisture.

As for the best sump pump brand, it depends on your specific needs. The sump pump is necessary, for example, for people with houses located in low-lying areas and flat lands where floods are most likely to occur. A good sump pump can save you thousands of dollars in damages whenever flood occurs because your basement and ground floor is free of groundwater, thus any heavy rain will be more readily absorbed by the ground.

4 thoughts on “Best Sump Pump Reviews 2017 – 2018

  1. My cement backyard/driveway, in a heavy rainfall, collects excessive water ( 6 to 12 inches ), and floods my garage. I need to pump the water out to the street, 50 feet away. Would the Wayne PC2 115-volt 340 GPH Portable Transfer Water Pump work? How much would such a unit cost? I live in California. Could I buy it at Home Depot? Thanks for your help. Don

Comments are closed.